|
Introduction
Salary
sacrifice allows basic rate tax paying employees
to increase pension payments by up to 31% at no
financial cost. This increase is paid for purely by savings made
in Income Tax and National Insurance. In November 2004 the Treasury gave a green light
to salary sacrifice that will cost the Chancellor
more than £1 billion a year in lost taxes.
A great number of employees in the
UK, irrespective of their salary, can benefit
from salary sacrifice. By making some simple adjustments
to their salary the employee that contributes
to a pension can take home the same income but
see their pension contributions increase by 31%,
this amount in addition to the tax advantages
already given to pension arrangements. Only employees in a money purchase such as group
personal or stakeholder pensions or employees
with no pension arrangement are considered. However,
it is possible for employees with a final salary
pension to use Salary Sacrifice.
Salary Sacrifice Schemes are legal and allow employers
to pay pension contributions on behalf of the
employee in return for a reduction in salary.
By doing this there is a saving in employee taxation
and National Insurance contributions for both
employee and employer. The lucrative benefits of salary sacrifice has
resulted in a number of major companies adopting
the schemes such as BT, LogicaCMG, Tesco and Sainsbury. They are likely to be followed by small to medium
companies due to the low cost of implementation
to the employer, up to 68% less than a traditional
group personal or stakeholder pension where the
total contribution to the scheme is 10% of payroll.
Example given: To explain how salary sacrifice works, the individual
examples assume an employee on £24,000 salary
contributing 5% net (£1,200 pa or £100
pm net) to a pension. However, salary sacrifice
can apply to any employee on any salary.
National Insurance
In April 2002 the Chancellor announced a significant
increase of National Insurance contributions for both employees
and employers effective from 6 April 2003 as follows:
Year |
Employee |
Employer |
2002/03 |
10% |
11.8% |
2003/04 |
11% |
12.8% |
2009/10 |
11% |
12.8% |
|
Although direct personal taxation and corporate tax has decreased
since the 1980's, this has been offset by increases in Value
Added Tax (VAT) and National Insurance (NI) contributions.
It is unlikely that this approach will change in the foreseeable
future and therefore both employee and employers can benefit
from the use of tax mitigating schemes, such as salary sacrifice
that particularly benefits from the mitigation of employers
NI contributions.
Savings gap
The savings gap is the difference between the actual savings
in the UK by individuals and the required estimated savings
to provide a suitable retirement income. In the UK the savings
gap is currently estimated to be £27 billion.
Traditionally pensions have been promoted as a very tax efficient
savings vehicle. This has been in the of a Net Pay Scheme
such as a personal pension or stakeholder pension, however
to bridge the savings gap employees and employers must implement
schemes that encourage greater savings.
A Salary Sacrifice Scheme is one option that goes some way
to achieving this with minimal financial cost to both employee
and employer.
Net Pay Scheme
Where an individual makes a personal contribution to a pension
plan, the Government gives a tax incentive. This also includes
a group personal pension or group stakeholder pension scheme
and the following calculation shows how a £100 pm contribution
(or £1,200 pa) is 'grossed up' and invested in the pension
plan.
Pension paid by employee:
|
£ |
£ |
|
|
|
Net pension |
|
1,200 |
|
|
|
Add: 22% tax on gross |
338 |
|
|
|
|
Gross pension |
|
1,538 |
|
|
|
Increase in pension |
|
28.21% |
This 'grossing up' means an extra 28.21% is invested in the
plan immediately for every contribution made, or £128.21
pm rather than £100 pm.
This is how the Government encourages employees to invest
in a pension for their retirement and is effectively a return
of income tax foe all money invested in a pension plan.
Salary Sacrifice Scheme
As an alternative to the Net Pay Scheme, the employee can opt for a salary
sacrifice scheme. Under this arrangement the employee opts
to sacrifice part of their gross income for a corresponding
pension contribution.
This pension contribution is treated as an employer's contribution
by the Inland Revenue. In order to maintain the employees
take home income, the amount of salary they must sacrifice
would be £149 pm (or £1,791 pa) based on a basic
rate tax salary of £24,000 pa as follows:
Pension paid by employer:
|
£ |
£ |
|
|
|
Net pension |
1,200 |
|
|
|
|
add: NI employee savings |
197 |
|
add: Income tax savings |
394 |
|
|
|
|
Salary sacrifice |
|
1,791 |
|
|
|
add: NI employer savings |
229 |
|
|
|
|
Gross pension |
|
2,020 |
|
|
|
Increase in pension |
|
68.35% |
|
|
|
In the above example the employer invests in the employee's
pension plan the salary sacrifice amount of £1,791 and
the employer National Insurance savings of £229 making
a gross pension contribution of £2,020 pa.
This results in an extra 68.35% being invested in the plan immediately
for every contribution made, or £168.33 pm rather than
£100 pm for a basic rate taxpayer. For a higher rate taxpayer
the increase is 91.2%, or £191.20 pm rather than £100
pm.
This increase is 31.34% higher per contribution than a Net Pay
Scheme and the employee's take home income remains unchanged.
Income unchanged
When an employee opts for a salary sacrifice scheme rather than
a Net Pay Scheme they sacrifice part of their gross income for
a corresponding pension contribution paid by the employer. This
means that if employees are contributing to a pension, they
will stop the contributions and the employer will pay them instead.
The following example is based on an employee contributing £100
pm (or £1,200 pa) net. The employee's gross income will
reduce from £24,000 pa to £22,209 pa. Taxation is
based on rates and allowances for the 2004/05 tax year.
|
Current Scheme
(£) |
Salary Sacrifice
(£) |
|
24,000 |
22,209 |
|
3,994 |
3,600 |
|
2,188 |
1,991 |
|
1,200 |
0 |
|
16,618 |
16,618 |
Example - Assumes an employee is
on a salary of £24,000 paying £120 pm
net (or £1,200 pa) and sacrifice £1,791
pa salary. The employer is responsible for the pension
payment of £2,020 pa gross. |
|
|
There is no change in take home income because although under
the Salary Sacrifice Scheme gross salary has reduced so has
income tax, NI contributions and the responsibility for pension
payments is now the employers. Net income is the same at £16,618
per annum even though gross income has been reduced by £1,791
per annum.
Pension increase
In a traditional Net Pay Scheme the employee pays their
pension contributions out of their net pay and this is 'grossed
up' when invested into the pension plan. The employer may
also choose to contribute. However, in a Salary Sacrifice
Scheme the employer pays into the employees pension plan as
follows.
Who pays what and from where |
|
Current Scheme |
Salary Sacrifice |
|
employee |
employer |
|
1,200 |
0 |
|
0 |
1,791 |
|
0 |
229 |
|
338 |
0 |
|
1,538 |
2,020 |
Example - Assumes an employee is
on a salary of £24,000 paying 5% of salary
into a pension. Take home pay for both current and
Salary Sacrifice Scheme is £16,918 per annum. |
|
|
In a Salary Sacrifice Scheme the employer invests the salary
sacrificed by the employee, £1,791 pa and also the employer
NI savings of £229 pa. The employer's NI is saved because
the employer pays a smaller gross salary to the employee,
£22,209 instead of £24,000 in this example.
This means the gross pension increases from £1,538 per
annum in a Net Pay Scheme to £2,020 per annum for the
Salary Sacrifice Scheme, an increase of 31.34% for every contribution
made.
Long term growth
Salary Sacrifice Schemes benefit significantly from the
extra 68.35% increase in pension contribution paid by the
employer for basic rate taxpayers and 91.2% for higher rate
taxpayers.
This compares to a Net Pay Scheme where the extra increase
is 28.21% for a basic rate taxpayer and 66.67% for a higher
rate taxpayer.
Saving £100 pm for 10 years |
Investment |
Fund Value (£) |
|
26,400 |
|
20,422 |
|
17,160 |
|
15,958 |
Assumes 7% growth per annum for
pension and Salary Sacrifice Scheme and 1% charges.
Assumes charges for Cash ISA and bank account is
0% and growth rate of 4% per annum. |
|
|
The above schemes are not directly comparable as the cash
based plans can be accessed 100% as tax free cash whereas
the pension based plans are restricted to 25% tax free cash
with an income paid for the balance. At retirement the employee can use the much greater pension fund to purchase an annuity, before making a decision regarding a pension income, learn more about annuities, compare annuity rates and secure a personalised annuity quote offering guaranteed rates.
|